+44 203 290 6685 info@valiant-wealth.com

Pensions in Italy, as with many things, are dominated by the state. The state is the primary provider for people in their retirement and the pension system (known as The First Pillar) is funded by social security contributions made by workers and employers. When coming from a country where the emphasis is on private pensions such as the UK, the level of social security contributions can come as a shock, especially for the self-employed.

To make matters worse, it is far from certain what people making contributions into the system now will get back in the future with some estimates showing the system will collapse long before many of us reach pension age, which is also increasing at a steady rate. The article claims that INPS will implode in 2030 due to Italy’s ageing population and Tito Boeri (president of INPS until February 2019) states that the obvious answer is to encourage immigration which, with a properly implemented policy, would not only solve a looming pension crisis but make Italy an economic powerhouse once again. Immigration is a controversial subject in Italy at present and is unlikely to be encouraged over the coming years. 

The result is that for younger workers (or anyone under the age of 56 if we believe the above) who may not be able to rely on the state to return the money they have invested into their INPS pension, private pensions take on a greater importance than they have in the past in Italy.

This brings us to what is known as ‘The Second Pillar’, which are supplementary pensions or ‘prevedenza complementare’. Unlike the UK system where employers are now obliged to setup a pension scheme for employees and make contributions, this is not the case in Italy so as an employee you may or may not be offered access to a private pension and as a self-employed person it is, naturally, entirely up to you to organise a Piano Individuale Pensionistico (PIP) or Fondi Pensione Aperto (FPA), which are similar although FPAs are preferable as they are generally lower cost and there is more flexibility around contributions.

If you work for a company which provides a good benefits package it is likely that there will be an occupational scheme. Legislation came into force in 2007 which obliges companies to redirect what they would have otherwise paid into a TFR (obligatory severance pay scheme) for an employer, into a private pension instead only if the employee opts to make contributions into the pension. The take-up of these pensions has been low, particularly among younger workers, as they have lower salaries so less disposable income to save, have less job security so prefer a TFR payment when leaving a job rather than tying money up into a pension. Once again, ironic in that younger workers are those most at risk of not receiving the full value of the INPS pension they are paying for.

In addition to this, there are limited tax benefits offered for supplementary pensions in Italy, currently income tax relief is given on only €5,164.57 per annum of pension contributions. The income received from this type of pension is taxed at a favourable rate (starting at 15%) if you are above the state retirement age and there are some circumstances where you can access the funds prior to state retirement age, such as being unemployed for an extended period, but you are then taxed at a higher rate on the income.

Generally pensions work on the basis that you receive tax relief on contributions and pay tax on income. This encourages contributions into a structure where your money is essentially locked away and inaccessible for what could be decades. If you are not receiving tax benefits, or they are negligible for doing this then saving into a pension becomes unattractive.

For the self-employed, of which there are many in Italy, the situation is made worse by the products available. PIPs are almost entirely offered by Insurance companies while FPAs are also offered by some banks and investment management firms. An unfortunate aspect of my job is that annually I have to trawl through the product information of many of these to see if we could actually recommend any of them as being a good solution. The cost, limited investment options with poor returns and lack of flexibility do not make them appealing. Some are better than others but it feels like picking the best of a bad bunch.

Occupational schemes sometimes offer a more attractive option than FPAs and PIPs, as large organisations will negotiate preferential terms with a provider for their employees. However, it is important to assess the pros and cons of the scheme before committing.

We believe that there are far better ways to save money than these products and while legislation remains the same there is a negligible tax advantage in saving into an FPA, PIP or an occupational scheme unless your employer is making considerable contributions, at least above TFR levels.

In conclusion, considering the problems INPS face in the future the private pension system is in dire need of reform. However, the bottom line is that Italian residents need to save for retirement and cannot rely on the state to support pensioners to a reasonable level as they do now.

While private pension options and the level of tax relief currently available are underwhelming there are alternatives which can provide a cost effective platform to save and grow money and when they are of reasonable value there are Italian compliant tax efficient structures which can be used which would likely allow a more efficient retirement plan than using a traditional pension in Italy.

If you would like more information about this then please get in touch, we are happy to speak to people and offer an initial retirement planning consultation free of charge and without obligation.

FINANCIAL ADVICE FOR EXPATS IN ITALY

Do UN employees need a Supplementary Pension?

We think not, which is not to say that UN employees do not need to save for retirement but the question should be what is the most suitable way for a UN employee to save for retirement? This article expands on one of the points we made in our previous article titled...

RAISING STANDARDS IN FINANCIAL ADVICE FOR EXPATS

Valiant Wealth are setting new standards in independent financial advice for international people and expats resident in Italy. This article was originally published by Italian Insider – an English language newspaper and website for expats in Italy.

The ‘Greta Thunberg Effect’ and The Rise of ESG Investing

By Adam Smith As you have probably heard Greta Thunberg had quite a 2019 which resulted in her being named the 2019 Time person of the year. The level of attention she has brought to the climate crisis is quite astonishing especially considering she was 16 years old...

Move to Italy and enjoy ‘La Dolce Vita’ on tax!

Why Italy should be your first choice escape route Whether you’re a middle-aged professional with an established career, an entrepreneur or just starting out in the world of work, Italy should be top of your list thanks to favourable new tax regimes. Italy offers a...

The Age of the Italian Tax Incentive

From a tax perspective there has probably never been a better time to move to Italy, in modern history at least. In recent years Italy has been following Portugal and Cyprus’s lead and attempting to attract new residents made up of retirees, high net worth individuals...

Substitutive Tax Regime Attracts Wealthy Foreign Citizens to Italy

In 2017 Italy Finance Law introduced a flat rate of tax of €100,000 aimed at attracting high net worth foreigners to reside in Italy. The law states that new residents will pay only a flat lump sum tax of €100,000 in place of normal income tax. As with any new...

How Much Do I Need to Save for Retirement?

Have you given thought to what the sunset years of your life will look like? If your dream is have the freedom to travel and have fun then you might need to take a good hard look at your financial situation today.   It all starts by asking yourself a few simple...

QUESTIONS TO ASK A FINANCIAL ADVISOR

This article delves into questions you should be asking your financial advisor. Whether you’re about to start speaking to an advisor or you are already working with one, it is absolutely imperative that they can provide satisfactory answers to these questions. We’ve...

UNDERSTANDING INPS

What is INPS in Italy? The National Institute of Social Security ( INPS ) is the main social security institution of the Italian public pension system, in which all public or private employees must be enrolled and most of the self-employed workers who do not have...

HEALTH INSURANCE FOR EXPATS IN ITALY

We are often asked about health insurance in Italy, in some cases from people moving to Italy who have heard about the need for health cover in order to gain residence status and others who are concerned about the level of care they may receive if they are taken ill...

Get in touch for a FREE consultation

We firmly believe that your location in the world should not be a barrier to receiving fair, independent and transparent financial advice that you can trust.

We work with clients across the globe and can offer you a FREE initial consultation wherever you are.

It all starts by getting in touch!

Simply complete the contact form and someone will be in touch for an informal chat to discuss how we can help.